In 2004, Suffolk County bought the Scully Estate on South Bay Avenue because the land was at risk of being sold for private development. That is how Seatuck Environmental Association executive director Enrico Nardone put it to Newsday. His group had lobbied for the purchase. Twenty-two years later, on October 31, 2026, Seatuck finished moving out and ended its 20-year stewardship of the property.
The 70 acres were protected by the way the county paid for them, and that has not changed. Seatuck's departure leaves a narrower question for Islip: who takes care of a 1917 house and its grounds, and on what terms. That was also the question that wore out the last arrangement.
The Protection Came With the Purchase
Seatuck's farewell page explains why it expects the estate to stay a preserve. The county bought the property with open space funding and dedicated it to the Suffolk County Historic Trust, so the group says it is "confident it will remain a nature preserve and open as a public resource." County lawmakers said the same thing in public over the summer. Legislator Steven Flotteron, who represents the area, told Newsday that the property's preserved status "will be forever." Legislator Samuel Gonzalez said he had spoken with the county executive's office and that "they are not selling."
The land covers a lot of ground. The 70 acres hold salt marsh, freshwater wetlands and upland forest near the Great South Bay, and Seatuck describes the site as adjacent to both Seatuck National Wildlife Refuge and Islip Town Beach. Newsday called it "one of the few large areas of untouched woods on Long Island's South Shore." The house at the center of the property has passed through several owners:
- The parcel was part of Windholme Farm, an estate of nearly 300 acres owned by Samuel and Adaline Peters. Newsday, citing the county parks website, dates the farm from the late 1880s to the early 1900s.
- In 1917, a Normandy-style house called Wereholme, designed by Grosvenor Atterbury, was built for the Peters' daughter Louisine and Harold Weekes.
- Hathaway "Happy" Scully pledged the property for a wildlife sanctuary and nature center, and Audubon took title in the early 1980s.
- Suffolk County bought the property in June 2004, restored the building to LEED standards between 2006 and 2010, and opened it as the Suffolk County Environmental Center on Earth Day in April 2010.
- Seatuck managed the property under an agreement with the county from at least 2007 until October 31, 2026.
Over that whole span, the land kept its status even as the caretaker changed. Atterbury's name also turns up elsewhere in Islip. He is credited as the designer of Bayberry Point, the canal community off the bay in the same hamlet.
The Job Seatuck Handed Back
The Newsday account shows that the hard part at Scully was always the upkeep. Nardone said Suffolk County and Seatuck never agreed to a new contract after the last one expired in 2018. He pointed to the pandemic, vague contract language and bureaucratic delays. The contract included no direct county funding, and Nardone described the group as "self-funded." Newsday reported Seatuck's annual revenue at just under $1.4 million on its 2024 tax forms.
Nardone also described the maintenance clause. "One of the things that was always a challenge was that we were responsible for 'day-to-day' maintenance. That's sort of a vague term, right?" he said. Flotteron described the burden from the county's side. "It's a big responsibility when we turn over all of this square footage … with maintenance and things that they agreed to do," he said.
Seatuck's reason for leaving is about its mission more than the estate. Nardone said the group now wants to push for policy change and regional projects. One example is new roadway infrastructure to protect river otters where they cross roads, a species once nearly wiped out on Long Island. "Taking care of a big old building on a big property was a lot," he told the paper. Seatuck's own page says it is grateful to have shared the property with so many visitors over two decades. It also says its conservation and education programs will continue without interruption.
So whoever runs the estate next takes on the same building, the same acreage and the same maintenance question Seatuck carried through eight years without a renewed contract.
What the County's Own Records Show
In August 2026, Historic Trust Director Richard Martin told the Suffolk County Council on Environmental Quality, according to its meeting summary, that the tenant had vacated the housing unit at the Scully Estate. He said Suffolk County Parks would renovate and reappraise the unit, then "work to have this housing unit occupied as soon as possible." He also gave an update on the property as a whole and on Seatuck's decision to leave at the end of October. The next line of the record, under Historic Trust custodial agreements, reads "No updates at this time."
Taken together, the record and the summer reporting point to a new custodial agreement as the next formal step. Flotteron told Newsday that the county plans to seek organizations interested in taking over stewardship, though the timing of that search was unclear when the paper reported it in July. Nardone said he felt "very confident that the county is committed to maintaining it as open space and a public resource."
Seatuck sends anyone hoping to hold a wedding, event or photo shoot at the estate to the Suffolk County Department of Parks at 631-854-4949. The county's Scully Estate page has the address and the property's history.
Islip residents may also wonder about the land next door. Seatuck National Wildlife Refuge, at 500 St. Marks Lane, is run by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. It is closed to the public except for select permitted uses such as research and environmental education. The refuge is a separate federal property and does not change with Seatuck's move.
Where the Programs Went
Seatuck's staff now work out of two other sites. One is the South Shore Nature Center in East Islip, and the other is its new Coastal Restoration & Innovation Center in West Sayville. For an Islip family, the East Islip site is the one that matters.
The South Shore Nature Center at 130 Bayview Avenue is a 200-acre preserve with trails, boardwalks, a visitor center, interactive exhibits and live animals. That is almost three times the acreage at Scully. Seatuck lists the grounds as open daily from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. and the visitor center as open weekends from 1 to 4 p.m., with occasional weekday hours depending on staff schedules. Pets are not allowed.
Seatuck's children's programs run there now. Seatuck's after-school Naturalist Club for kindergarten through sixth grade meets at South Shore through December 17. The fee is $300 per three-month session, and the fall dates continue on December 1 through 3, 8 through 10 and 15 through 17. Tiny Trekkers, for ages 2 to 5, meets Tuesdays at 1:30 p.m. at the same site. Seatuck describes its general-public program series as free, and it says details for 2027 are coming. The November 14 Evening Owl Prowl at South Shore was listed as full, so it is worth booking early when the next dates appear.
The two winter events on Seatuck's calendar are off-site. A Winter Waterfowl Spectacle is set for December 12 from 9 to 11 a.m. at Cupsogue County Park in Westhampton Beach. A second one starts at 9 a.m. on January 9, 2027, at the Marine Nature Study Area in Oceanside. Both take registration through Seatuck's site.
The Coastal Restoration & Innovation Center is at 132 Clyde Street at the West Sayville Boat Basin. Seatuck calls it a hub for applied science and coastal and estuarine restoration, and the work includes oyster-restoration experiments run by a hatchery manager and technician. It is a working facility more than a place for a Saturday visit, but it ties Seatuck's future to the same Great South Bay that borders the Scully Estate.
For anyone who lives off South Bay Avenue or walks to Islip Town Beach, the practical picture for the rest of the year is this. The estate stays county land under the Historic Trust. Suffolk Parks at 631-854-4949 takes inquiries about events on the grounds. Seatuck's naturalists are at 130 Bayview Avenue in East Islip. Our Islip neighborhood page and the fall post on what changes at Heckscher after Columbus Day cover more open space close to home.
Irene Siconolfi brings more than 25 years of Long Island experience to questions about the South Shore's open spaces and the homes around them. If you have a question about this corner of Islip, or about life near the bay here, Work With Irene. She is glad to talk it through.